Skip to main content
All Posts

What Is a Holding Statement, and When Do You Need One?

A holding statement acknowledges a developing situation when important facts remain uncertain. Knowing what can responsibly be said, what should remain unanswered, and whether a statement is necessary at all requires sound judgment.

Crisis Communications
·5 min read

At a Glance

  • A holding statement acknowledges a developing situation without making premature commitments before the facts are established.
  • The first question isn't how quickly we can draft something. It's what we know, what remains uncertain and whether speaking now serves a useful purpose.
  • Sometimes an immediate response is warranted. Sometimes it's better to wait for verified information. And sometimes no statement is necessary.
Split cover reading “What is a holding statement, and when do you need one?” beside a U.S. Coast Guard photograph of supply vessels spraying water on the burning Deepwater Horizon rig in the Gulf of Mexico, April 2010.
Summarize this article
ChatGPTClaudePerplexityGemini

In the early coverage of the Deepwater Horizon spill in 2010, corporate and federal narratives dominated. National coverage struggled to show the scale of the damage, and what it meant for people on the Gulf Coast, in real time. Frontline organizations risked being reduced to secondary voices.

We worked with one of them, Mobile Baykeeper, in a volatile, fast-moving news cycle. In a crisis that is still unfolding, an organization may have to speak before the facts are in. A "holding statement" is what it says then. Its value lies particularly in what it avoids committing to before the facts are known.

What is a holding statement?

A holding statement acknowledges a developing situation when the facts remain uncertain, allowing an organization to respond without rushing to conclusions or making premature commitments. Its purpose is to preserve credibility while the facts are established. A press release serves a different purpose: communicating verified information, providing meaningful context and establishing a newsworthy reason for journalists to report the story. One protects credibility when answers are still emerging; the other supports informed reporting when there is something substantive to say.

A holding statement isn't intended to fill a news vacuum with speculation. During Deepwater Horizon, the question was whether dispersants were making oil less visible without resolving the environmental threat. At Fukushima, it was whether radioactive releases threatened human health, drinking water and food safety before the full extent of exposure was known. In either case, the responsible response was to acknowledge the concern, distinguish what was known from what remained uncertain, and insist on credible evidence before drawing conclusions.

The order of the first hours is in our crisis communications plan; this post stays with the one statement.

What a holding statement avoids committing to

The first question is not how quickly we can draft something. It is what we know, what remains uncertain and whether speaking now serves a useful purpose. Speed without a fact base is improvisation.

A holding statement acknowledges a developing situation without making commitments or drawing conclusions the available evidence cannot support. Sometimes that is appropriate. Sometimes the better decision is to wait.

During the Deepwater Horizon crisis, our work with Mobile Baykeeper required something more substantial: establishing the facts, identifying credible spokespeople and maintaining message discipline as new information emerged. Local testimony had to connect with the broader national consequences of the spill without getting ahead of the evidence.

Who hears it first, and who says it

We sequence coalition and stakeholder notification so an organization's own people hear it first.

Who speaks is part of that fact base. For Mobile Baykeeper, we positioned the organization as a primary, on-the-ground authority and translated environmental harm into clear stories about livelihoods, public health and accountability. It became a trusted national source.

The answer is different in a different crisis. With Physicians for Social Responsibility, in acute crises such as the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster in 2011, nuclear incidents were treated as technical failures and the human health consequences were obscured. We positioned physicians as frontline interpreters of risk and elevated medical voices during high-stakes moments. We have written more about knowing who your audience trusts.

What a holding statement could say in two crises

Deepwater Horizon: Mobile Baykeeper, 2010

During the BP oil spill, one of our concerns was whether chemical dispersants were pushing oil beneath the Gulf's surface, making the pollution less visible without reducing its environmental consequences. A holding statement could acknowledge that concern without suggesting BP deliberately concealed the oil or claiming to know the full extent of the damage. The essential point was straightforward: Oil disappearing from view doesn't mean the pollution has disappeared. Until independent monitoring established the consequences for marine life, coastal waters and fisheries, the public deserved answers about where the oil was going and what risks remained.

Fukushima Daiichi: Physicians for Social Responsibility, 2011

Following the Fukushima nuclear disaster, Physicians for Social Responsibility had a legitimate public-health concern: whether radioactive releases threatened people through exposure to contaminated air, drinking water or food. Radioactive iodine and cesium raised particular concerns for children and other vulnerable populations. A holding statement could establish those risks without prematurely asserting how many people had been exposed, whether particular food or water supplies were unsafe, or what the eventual health consequences would be. The point wasn't to predict the damage, but to explain the potential dangers, identify what remained unknown and insist on independent monitoring and credible public-health information.

In both cases, the value of a holding statement was its restraint: acknowledge the legitimate concern, establish what was known, and avoid conclusions the evidence couldn't yet support.

When you need one, and when you do not

The questions come before the draft. What changed? What can be verified? What decisions remain open? What needs to happen next? Those questions should guide the response before we decide what to communicate.

Sometimes the right move is to speak immediately. Sometimes it's better to wait until the facts support a public response. Knowing the difference is part of the work.

In practice, we don't use holding statements particularly often. They're one tool among many, and only useful when the circumstances warrant one.

After the holding statement

Facts change. Other parties respond. News coverage evolves. We adjust the argument, spokespeople and supporting materials as an issue develops rather than treating the first news cycle as the finish line.

During the Deepwater Horizon crisis, our work with Mobile Baykeeper helped connect an offshore environmental disaster to its consequences for Gulf Coast communities, marine ecosystems and local economies. That engagement lasted 87 days, requiring sustained media outreach, credible local voices and adjustments as new information emerged.

If something is live right now, our crisis communications firm page says how we work.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a holding statement the same as a press release?

No. A press release communicates established information with a newsworthy purpose. A holding statement acknowledges a developing situation when important facts remain uncertain, without making premature commitments or drawing unsupported conclusions.

Does a holding statement only apply when the organization caused the problem?

No. A crisis isn't necessarily something an organization caused. Often, it's something happening to the issue it works on. Mobile Baykeeper didn't cause the Deepwater Horizon disaster, but the spill directly threatened the coastal communities, waters and marine ecosystems it works to protect.

Aric Caplan

Aric Caplan

Founder, Caplan Communications

Aric Caplan has advised national nonprofits, coalitions, and public agencies on high-stakes communications for more than two decades. He founded Caplan Communications in 2004, building a practice grounded in integrating earned media, message strategy, and rapid response into policy and regulatory processes. His work spans climate action, environmental protection, civil rights, and public health.

Share this article

Get in Touch

We mainstream what matters.

If you’re navigating a high-stakes communications challenge, we’d welcome a conversation.